How to Compare Repair Quotes (Without Getting Burned)
Educational explainer. U.S.-focused; prices vary by state/region and by vehicle.
Comparing repair quotes is hard because shops quote different scopes. Use a checklist approach so you aren’t comparing apples to oranges.
Checklist: Same parts quality, same labor scope, same warranty, and clear diagnostics.
The scope checklist
- What exact part(s) are being replaced?
- Are fluids, gaskets, sensors included?
- Is programming/calibration included?
Warranty and risk
A cheap quote with a weak warranty can be expensive later. Read the warranty details.
When to get a second diagnosis
If the repair is very expensive or the diagnosis feels vague, a second opinion can be worth the fee.
FAQ
Should I choose the cheapest quote?
Not automatically. Compare scope and warranty first.
Are diagnostic fees a scam?
Not inherently. Diagnosis is labor. The issue is when it’s vague or not documented.